Life After the Championship: The Cost per Goal
Cardiff are going straight back up after one season. Plymouth and Luton, relegated at the same time, are not. Burton Albion have been in League One for eight years. What does the data reveal about who actually gets out?
● Live data, updated every 6 hours
The Same Division, Three Completely Different Seasons
Cardiff City, Plymouth Argyle and Luton Town were all relegated from the EFL Championship in the summer of 2025. All three arrived in League One with similar backgrounds: recent top-flight or Championship experience, wage bills built for a higher level, and the expectation that they would not stay long.
As the season draws to a close, only one of them has secured the return. Cardiff have confirmed promotion in second place, with 80 goals scored and just 6 games without scoring all season.
Plymouth sit seventh. Luton sit eighth. Both have had decent campaigns, both score regularly, and neither is going up. Then there is Burton Albion, relegated from the Championship back in the 2017/18 season, who sit 18th with 46 goals and 16 games without scoring. Eight years later, they are still here.
How Likely Is a First-Season Escape?
Three clubs are relegated from the Championship each season, and three are promoted from League One. But those promotion places are not reserved for the newly arrived — they are shared across all 24 clubs. Looking at the last four years of relegations, 12 clubs have dropped from the Championship to League One. Only two went straight back up in their first season, a rate of one in six. Some take two or three years. Some, like Burton, settle in and never leave. The clubs relegated in 2022/23 included Wigan, Reading and Blackpool. None of them went straight back up.
The Number That Actually Explains the Gap
Plymouth average 1.60 goals scored per game this season. Luton average 1.42. Both figures are comfortably above the League One average. On attacking output alone, both clubs would be expected to push for the top six. Neither has.
The reason is in the goals conceded column. Plymouth concede at 1.37 per game. Luton concede at 1.23. Cardiff concede at 1.02. That gap, less than half a goal per game between Cardiff and Plymouth, is where the promotion race has been decided.
The Financial Reality Behind the Numbers
Finance shapes everything in English football, and League One is no different. Cardiff's estimated wage bill for 2025/26 is around £14.3 million per year, approximately £275,000 per week. That is not a League One budget. It reflects a Championship-level squad they could not dismantle quickly enough after relegation, built when the club carried the seventh-highest wage bill in the Championship despite finishing bottom.
Burton's estimated wage bill for the same season is around £5.3 million per year, roughly £101,000 per week. Cardiff are spending more than 2.5 times as much.
What the Plymouth and Luton example makes clear, though, is that financial weight alone does not explain first-season success. Both clubs arrived with elevated wage structures from their Championship years, and both are finishing in the top half. The money provides the platform. Cardiff converted it.
The clearest cautionary tale is Rotherham United, relegated from the Championship in 2023/24 and now finishing 22nd in League One, heading to League Two. They have conceded 65 goals this season at a rate of 1.51 per game, among the worst defensive records in the division. The financial cost of a second successive relegation, in lost prize money, lower gate receipts and the work of rebuilding for the fourth tier, will considerably outweigh any saving made by cutting the wage bill on the way down.
Is There a Pattern Across the Division?
Cardiff and Burton are not isolated cases. This season's League One contains 11 clubs who have spent time in the Championship within the last decade, and 13 clubs who are more naturally at home in the third tier.
When you average out the goals figures across both groups, a pattern does emerge. Former Championship clubs average — goals scored per game and concede at — per game. League One natives average — scored and — conceded.
The difference in attacking output between the two groups is modest. The more interesting observation is in goals conceded, where the former Championship clubs, taken as a whole, do not show a meaningful defensive advantage. The higher-tempo, more open style those clubs tend to bring with them cuts both ways.
Goals Per Game — Ex-Championship vs League One Natives
Data via API-Football. Ex-Championship classification based on EFL Championship history within the last decade.
The Barnsley Anomaly
The most open team in the division is not Cardiff. It is Barnsley, another former Championship club, who average 3.14 total goals per game, the highest in League One. They score at 1.55 per game and concede at 1.60.
The result? Twelfth place. Barnsley's numbers illustrate the same point as Plymouth and Luton: attacking output without defensive structure produces entertainment, not promotion. It is a reminder that open football and successful football are not the same thing at this level.
What Eight Years Does to a Club
Burton Albion were a League Two club as recently as 2015. They rose through the divisions, reached the Championship, and were relegated back to League One in 2018. They have not left since.
Their statistics this season read like a club that has gradually adapted to its surroundings rather than fought against them. 12 clean sheets suggests a side that can organise defensively. But 16 games without scoring suggests a club that has, season by season, lost the attacking edge that gets you out of this division. Their wage bill reflects the same process: reduced year on year as high earners have departed and been replaced by players priced for the third tier.
The Burton story is one of remarkable resilience for a club of their size. But the data points to a club that has calibrated itself so precisely to League One that it no longer has the excess — in budget, in goals, or in ambition — that promotion requires.
What the Data Tells Us
How likely is a Championship club to get straight back out in year one? Based on recent history, not very. One in six is a reasonable approximation. Three clubs came down from the Championship in 2025. One is going back.
Cardiff's promotion is not explained by a single factor. Their wage bill provided a squad capable of performing above the level of the division. Their 80 goals show they used that quality in attack. But the figure that ultimately separates them from Plymouth and Luton, two clubs with very similar financial and competitive backgrounds, is the 1.02 goals they concede per game. That is not a number you build by accident. It is the product of organisation, work rate, and a manager who understood that getting out of League One is as much about what you prevent as what you produce.
Burton sit at the opposite end of every metric. Eight seasons of League One has produced a wage bill, a squad, and a style of play that are perfectly calibrated to the division. Whether that changes next season, the data does not say. What it does say is that the clubs who escape quickly are the ones who arrive still carrying something from the level above, and spend one season making sure it is put to use before the financial reality of the third tier begins to close in around them.